If you’re planning on visiting the Hamptons this summer, you’re in for a real treat. The Hamptons is renowned for its beautiful beaches, picturesque countryside, and fantastic dining scene. With so many dining options available, it can be overwhelming trying to decide where to go. Do you want a lively atmosphere with amazing bites in Montauk, or are you more in the mood for something laid-back with a view of the waterfront, perhaps some tacos?
Fear not, as this guide to the best classic Hamptons restaurants has got you covered. From quirky party buses with tropical rum cocktails to lobster rolls and fries, there’s something to suit every taste. Whether you’re looking for a romantic dinner with your significant other or a night out with friends, these classic Hamptons restaurants will not disappoint.
As you go through the guide, make sure to note down the ones that catch your eye and make the necessary reservations. Some of these restaurants may have a long waiting list, but trust us, they’re worth the wait! Get ready for an ultimate Hamptons dining experience this summer with this comprehensive guide.
Rumba
Rumba, located at 43 Canoe Place Rd in Hampton Bays, NY 11946, is a hidden gem among the Hamptons’ dining scene. It’s one of the most exciting and underrated dining experiences in the East End. The colorful and kitschy waterfront restaurant is positioned right on Shinnecock Bay, offering a breathtaking view of the sunset and a perfect setting to sip on a refreshing coconut mojito.
At Rumba, the cozy atmosphere, reggae tunes, and the sound of the waves will make you feel like you’re on a tropical island getaway. The menu features a plethora of delightful rum cocktails that are a must-try and pair perfectly with the seafood-centric fare. Be sure to try their fresh fish tacos and don’t miss out on an order of their melt-in-your-mouth plantains. You can also arrive by boat and dock it while you dine, adding a touch of adventure to your experience.
If you’re looking to celebrate a special occasion, Rumba is the perfect venue. The restaurant offers the “Rumbus,” a private party bus that’s available for reservation if you’re looking to have a one-of-a-kind celebration with your friends. So why wait? Head over to Rumba and experience the relaxing ambiance and delectable dishes that make it a top Hamptons dining destination.
Canal Cafe
Located at 44 Newtown Rd in Hampton Bays, NY 11946, this charming eatery is hidden away from the hustle and bustle of Hamptons dining scene. It’s a great waterfront option for those who don’t want to venture far from Hampton Bays and drive for over an hour to Montauk. The menu is packed with reliable options that are sure to satisfy your cravings. Lobster rolls, veggie burgers, fish tacos, and more are all available at this cozy eatery.
As for ambiance, the restaurant offers a relaxed and inviting atmosphere overlooking the marina. It’s a perfect spot to enjoy a lazy afternoon or a romantic dinner. However, the popularity of this spot means it can fill up quickly, so it’s recommended to either arrive early or be prepared to wait for a table. While waiting, grab a cocktail from the bar, take a stroll around the marina, and soak in the beautiful scenery.
Although it may be an under-the-radar spot, this waterfront eatery is one of the best kept secrets of Hampton Bays. Be sure to put it on your dining list when exploring the East End of Long Island.
Sant Ambroeus
Sant Ambroeus is a beloved Italian restaurant that has become a cherished dining destination in Southampton. Located at 30 Main St, Southampton, NY 11968, the restaurant has gained a reputation for serving some of the best pasta dishes in the Hamptons. It’s also a popular spot for people watching, offering a more low-key atmosphere compared to some of the flashier restaurants in the area. The establishment recently opened up a second location in East Hampton, at 66 Newtown Lane, East Hampton, NY 11937.
Both locations are open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, as well as all-day gelato and sorbet. If you’re looking for the perfect appetizer, try their renowned Asparagi Freddi. Made with steamed, fresh asparagus, tomato, and hard-boiled eggs, it’s a refreshing and light start to your meal. And be sure not to miss out on their pasta dishes – crowd favorites include the Cacio e Pepe and the Spaghetti Aglio.
Just make sure to save room for dessert, as Sant Ambroeus’ desserts are not to be missed. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic tiramisu or a decadent chocolate cake, their selection of desserts is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.
Both locations of Sant Ambroeus offer a unique and enjoyable dining experience, making it a must-try for anyone visiting the Hamptons.
Tutto Il Giorno
For those craving Italian cuisine, Tutto Il Giorno is the spot for you. With locations in Southampton (56 Nugent St., Southampton, NY 11968) and Sag Harbor (16 Main St., Sag Harbor, NY 11963), as well as a café in East Hampton, Tutto Il Giorno offers a fun atmosphere perfect for dinner with a group of friends or family.
The menu features mouth-watering pasta dishes, fresh fish, and other traditional Italian fare that are sure to satisfy anyone’s cravings. It’s the perfect spot for those looking for an authentic Italian dining experience with a unique twist.
The atmosphere at Tutto Il Giorno is lively and welcoming, making it the perfect spot for a memorable evening out. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just looking for a great meal, Tutto Il Giorno is sure to deliver. Be sure to make a reservation ahead of time, as this popular dining spot can fill up quickly, especially during the summer season.
Calissa
Calissa, located at 1020 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, NY 11976, is a must-visit destination for those looking for an upscale and elegant Mediterranean dining experience. The chic Greek restaurant is a local favorite and offers a taste of Mykonos in the heart of the Hamptons.
One of the standout dishes on their menu is the seafood pasta, made with fresh ingredients that perfectly capture the essence of the Mediterranean. Additionally, the mezze options, such as the avocado tzatziki and artichoke labneh, are super tasty and perfectly complement the entrees.
The lush garden adds an extra layer of charm to the atmosphere at Calissa, making it a perfect date night spot that’s ideal for a summertime evening meal. Moreover, Calissa boasts an extensive wine selection, featuring the largest collection of rosé in the entire Hamptons, which makes it the perfect spot for wine lovers.
So, whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just looking for a fantastic dining experience, don’t miss Calissa. It’s undoubtedly one of the best Mediterranean-inspired restaurants in the area and shouldn’t be missed.
Suki Zuki
If you’re in the mood for Japanese cuisine, make sure to check out this Hamptons institution, located at 688 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, NY 11976. This no-frills restaurant has been around for years and is open year-round, offering consistently delicious Japanese cuisine.
The Chicken Teriyaki Salad and Spicy Tuna Sandwich are two of the restaurant’s classic dishes and for a good reason. They’re both incredibly tasty and well-prepared. However, if you’re looking for a vegetarian option, try their fried tofu skewers – it won’t disappoint.
The restaurant’s simple decor and laid-back atmosphere provide a relaxing and enjoyable experience, making it a great option for a casual meal with friends or family. And the best part? It’s open year-round, so you can enjoy their delicious dishes no matter what season you’re visiting.
Overall, this Japanese restaurant is a definite must-try for foodies visiting the Hamptons. So, head on over and indulge in some of the best Japanese food on offer in the area.
K Pasa
For a more relaxed meal with a beautiful view, check out this Sag Harbor taco spot located at 2 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963. This trendy taqueria is situated by the water and offers healthy and delicious dishes with creative ingredients.
Inspired by Malibu, they offer plenty of vegan and vegetarian options, making it a great spot for those with dietary restrictions. Try their brunch or dinner options, and don’t hesitate to indulge in one of their unique frozen margaritas. With options like prickly pear or passion fruit, you’ll feel like you’re on vacation. And if you’re really looking to let loose, add a floater to your margarita for an extra kick!
The relaxed atmosphere and gorgeous view of the water make this spot perfect for a casual meal with friends or family. If you’re craving tacos with a twist, this is the place to be. They serve up some inventive and satisfying options that are sure to please everyone at the table.
In summary, this taco spot is a hidden gem in Sag Harbor, delivering fresh, flavorful dishes with healthy ingredients. Visit for the atmosphere, stay for the delicious food and unique frozen margaritas!
Sen
If you’re looking for a sushi spot in Sag Harbor that caters to everyone’s tastes, check out Sen located at 23 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963. This upscale Japanese restaurant provides an impressive menu that features a wide variety of dishes, making it an excellent choice for families and large groups.
Whether you’re in the mood for an elaborately crafted sushi roll or just want a comforting bowl of miso soup, Sen has got you covered. The restaurant has been open since 1994, which is a testament to the quality of food and service they provide. Moreover, the cozy ambiance makes it an ideal spot to enjoy a bowl of ramen in the winter or sip sake before a big night out in the summer.
In addition to their sushi menu, Sen also serves other dishes from the Japanese cuisine, so everyone can find something to suit their liking. There are warm and filling ramen options on the menu, as well as other tasty entrees that deliver excellent flavors.
Overall, Sen is a must-visit spot in Sag Harbor that delivers on quality and taste. It has a welcoming atmosphere, and the service is top-notch, making it a great option for an intimate dinner or a big night out with friends.
Estia’s Little Kitchen
For a unique dining experience, make sure to check out Estia’s Little Kitchen, located at 1615 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, Sag Harbor, NY 11963. This hidden gem on the outskirts of Sag Harbor Village delivers tasty recipes that are sure to make you feel like you’re dining at a friend’s house.
All of the restaurant’s ingredients are locally sourced and sustainable, and they even have their own kitchen garden on the premises. In recognition of their efforts, Estia’s has been given the “Snail of Approval” award for “using the Slow Food ideals of Good, Clean, and Fair food.”
The restaurant serves up American recipes infused with Southwestern flair year-round in a comfortable and charming dining room. Definitely try the guacamole and chips – they’re almost impossible to resist. Also, don’t forget to order a spicy margarita for a bit of a kick; after all, you are on vacation.
Estia’s Little Kitchen is ideal for those who crave authentic flavors and an inviting atmosphere. It’s an excellent spot to grab a meal with friends and family, where you can indulge in food that feels like home and actually supports the local community.
Overall, Estia’s Little Kitchen is a top pick for fans of American and Southwestern cuisine. Whether you’re a local or visiting the area, don’t miss out on this unique and tasty restaurant in Sag Harbor.
Le Bilboquet
If you’re looking for a glamorous atmosphere with upscale French cuisine, Le Bilboquet located right on the water in Sag Harbor is a must-visit. With a vibe that pays homage to St. Tropez, this unapologetically scene-y restaurant is perfect for a fun meal with endless glasses of rosé.
The restaurant’s chic decor and lively music create a perfect ambiance for enjoying some elevated French cuisine with friends or family. With a menu that features an impressive array of dishes that showcase French culinary techniques, there is something for everyone.
Le Bilboquet’s status as a scene-y hotspot is not surprising, given its location and ambiance, but the food is the real star of the show. The menu features a mix of savory and sweet options, ranging from classic French dishes to creative takes on Mediterranean fare.
Overall, Le Bilboquet is an ideal destination for those who enjoy a lively atmosphere, elevated cuisine, and impeccable service. Whether you’re visiting for brunch, lunch or dinner, you’ll be sure to have an unforgettable experience at this vibrant French restaurant.
Surf Lodge
Montauk’s Surf Lodge, located at 183 Edgemere St., is a popular destination known for its summertime concerts and flowing glasses of rosé. In addition to the entertainment, Surf Lodge is also a great spot to enjoy dinner, made even better with the restaurant’s recent collaboration with consulting chef David Boyle.
The Surf Lodge’s menu boasts contemporary coastal cuisine that emphasizes locally-sourced veggies and fresh seafood. From the freshest catches straight off the nearby fishing boats to the classic and delicious chicken fingers and lobster rolls, there is something for everyone on this menu.
Reservations are highly recommended, especially during peak season when the restaurant hosts live music performances. Dine outside and enjoy some of the best people watching around town while indulging in the tasty food and refreshing drinks.
Overall, Surf Lodge is a great place to relax, unwind, and enjoy delicious food and drinks while taking in the stunning Montauk scenery. The restaurant’s focus on locally-sourced ingredients guarantees that you’ll be feasting on the freshest produce and seafood available, while the live music performances and vibrant atmosphere guarantees a memorable dining experience.
Lobster Roll
If you’re looking for a classic seafood spot in the Hamptons, look no further than Lobster Roll (also known as “Lunch”). The original location in Amagansett, located at 1980 Montauk Hwy, has been a beloved favorite since the 1960s, with an expansive menu and ample seating both indoors and outdoors. It’s even been featured in the TV show “The Affair.”
Lobster Roll’s menu features a wide variety of seafood dishes, from the classic lobster roll to crab cakes, clam chowder, and plenty of other tasty options. The atmosphere is unfussy and laid-back, with a beachy vibe that’s perfect for a casual meal with friends or family.
More recently, Lobster Roll has opened up a second location in Southampton at 32 Montauk Hwy, though it only has indoor seating options.
Overall, Lobster Roll is a must-visit spot for seafood lovers, with a classic ambiance and a menu that offers something for everyone. Whether you’re dining in Amagansett or Southampton, you’re bound to have a delicious and satisfying meal at this beloved local institution.
Duryea’s
For an unforgettable dining experience that makes you feel like you’re in the South of France, head down to Duryea’s, located at 65 Tuthill Rd in Montauk. Although the restaurant doesn’t take reservations (with the exception of their Orient Point outpost), it certainly draws a crowd for its beautiful setting and delicious seafood dishes.
Duryea’s offers stunning water views, making it the ideal spot for a leisurely lunch or dinner. Once seated, make sure to order a glass of refreshing rosé and indulge in their splurge-worthy dishes, like their infamous lobster cobb salad which is priced at $97. Even if it’s a bit pricey, it’s a must-try dish with plenty of flavors and textures to enjoy.
The restaurant is known for its seafood, so make sure to choose one of their freshly-caught fish options on the menu. You can enjoy your meal in a relaxed environment with a “South of France” vibe without leaving the country.
Overall, Duryea’s is a special place that is well-worth the wait to get a seat. You get to enjoy delicious seafood dishes while taking in some of the best water views in town. Make sure to stop by this dining hotspot, and you won’t be disappointed!
Navy Beach
If you’re looking for a laid-back and unpretentious dining experience in Montauk, look no further than Navy Beach, located at 16 Navy Rd. This hidden gem is nestled on a private beach, making it the perfect spot to enjoy a relaxed meal while taking in the stunning natural scenery.
Navy Beach has both indoor and outdoor dining options, but we highly recommend trying to grab one of the outdoor picnic-style tables. There’s nothing more enjoyable than dining al fresco while feasting on fresh crudo and delicious salads.
This restaurant has a fantastic menu that offers a range of seafood dishes from the raw bar, grilled options to make-your-own poke bowls, and creative cocktails. Navy Beach is all about good food and good vibes.
Overall, Navy Beach is perfect for those seeking a laid-back and unpretentious dining experience while enjoying stunning beach-front views and fresh seafood. Their outdoor picnic-style tables and relaxed atmosphere will make you feel like you’re having a meal right on the sand, making it a must-visit spot in Montauk.